Moonlight Creamery

Irem Zengin 2 months ago

The sundae was fresh, well made, and the portions were generous. The staff was friendly, and the overall atmosphere was cozy. I would definitely come back to try more flavors!

Ethan M 3 months ago

I recently stopped by Moonlight Creamery in Fairport and tried the Deer Tracks ice cream. The flavor was delicious and the portion size was also impressive for the price, making it a great value. The reason I’m giving 4 stars instead of 5 is that I felt a little rushed while trying to decide what to order and I was disappointed to learn that samples aren’t offered. With so many tempting flavors, being able to try one before committing would have made the experience better. Overall, the ice cream itself was excellent and I’d definitely come back for another scoop.

NATO32Nations 4 months ago

My parents recommended this spot. While the location is a bit hard to find for those not familiar with the Fairport area, once you find it, you’ll be in dessert paradise. Here they have a wide variety of ice creams, as well as coffee, chocolates, sweets and shakes. I bought a trio of giant rice krispy treats as well as a toasted marshmallow shake (with actual toasted marshmallows). The place is small, while they do have tables, I recommend that you order and sit out near the canal for a better view of the area. What I think is unique is that they offer sampler trays for when you want to taste multiple flavors. Like a wine sampler but with ice cream.

Mara Cook 5 months ago

We came to check out the ice cream, and we were not disappointed. A regular can be broken into 2 flavors. I tried mocha cookie (a vegan, dairy-free, gluten-free flavor) and enjoyed it immensely. The texture is different, but still great. We also tried toasted coconut which was chock full of coconut and almond; Cannoli which tasted like chocchip cannoli filling; and Smore which was my husband's favorite. We plan to return to try some of the other treats that caught our attention - like the toasted marshmallow shake thatcomes with toasted marshmallows on top. The atmosphere was fun, the music not too loud for conversation, seats were comfortable.

Huntz Shaikz a year ago

Creative flavors, great service- lady at the counter walked us through our first time and gave us perfect recommendations. The ice cream is airy but thick at the same time with such a rich taste. Tried strawberry, oats, mint, and cherry which were all stellar. We did an ice cream sampler which let us try one scoop of 4 flavors for $9. They have other desserts and drinks available as well.